Crustal strength control on structures and metamorphism in collisional orogens

Although the upper crust is the most accessible among other crustal units, so far little attention was paid about its role on the continental collision style and on exhumation processes of metamorphic rocks. With this respect, several 2D thermo-mechanical numerical experiments of post-subduction continental collision were performed, which allowed investigating the interplay between surface processes, thermal history and rheology of the upper crust units. The viscous strength of upper and lower plate upper crust (U.U.C. and L.U.C.) was systematically changed, obtaining a reference set of experiments to which subsequently we applied enhanced erosion patterns and variable radiogenic heat productivity of the sediments. We obtained three classes of collisional style: 1) decoupled asymmetric; 2) coupled asymmetric; 3) coupled symmetric. In general, for high-rates of radiogenic heating, a strong U.U.C. leads to one-sided, asymmetric and coupled hot orogen, which shifts to two-sided symmetric for weaker U.U.C. Lower radiogenic heat productivities yield colder orogens, promoting more asymmetric orogens and eventually the decoupling between upper and lower plates. The enhanced erosion leads to narrower and colder orogens, affecting the collisional style only for a relatively strong L.U.C. rheology. Exhumation of high-grade metamorphic rocks mainly depends on the L.U.C. strength: a weak viscous rheology promotes pure shear thickening of the incoming crust in the orogenic front, which inhibits both burial and exhumation processes. Higher viscous strengths promote deeper subduction of the L.U.C., with subsequent heating, delamination, partial melting and exhumation of high-grade rocks via channel flow. Enhanced erosion, although not a necessary condition, favours the extrusion of the partially melted mid-crustal channel. Overall, the numerical experiments reproduce the first order structural and/or metamorphic patterns of several natural cases (Himalayas, Boehmian Massif, Eastern-Central Alps, Apennines) and further suggest that the upper crust rheology is one of the key parameters controlling the collisional style and exhumation processes.