[18F]DOPA PET for lesion definition and contouring using different thresholds in patients with gliomas

Background: Amino-acid (AA) PET has recently been endorsed by the ESTRO-EANO guidelines for RT-planning in glioblastomas, with recommended lesion-to-brain-ratio thresholds (1.6-1.8) derived from a biopsy-controlled FET-PET study. We aimed to compare target definition at [18F]DOPA-PET between the ESTRO-EANO thresholds and other biological-tumor-volume (BTV) thresholds (derived from the striatum) typically used in [18F]DOPA-PET. Methods: A retrospective analysis was conducted on glioma patients scanned with [18F]DOPA-PET/CT at our center between April 2021 and January 2024. 3D BTV was semi-automatically computed using a dedicated workstation (Philips HealthCare) with four thresholds: 1.6xSUVmean of background, 1.8xSUVmean of background, SUVmean and SUVmax of the contralateral striatum. The delineation accuracy of different thresholds was visually evaluated and a t-test was used to compare the different VOIs volumes (0.05 significance-level). Results: 50 patients were included (36 previously received surgery). Volume definition based on the striatum SUVmax was significantly smaller compared to other thresholds (2.1 cm3), resulting in inaccurate VOIs at visual inspection in 21/50 patients. No significant differences were highlighted in BTV defined based on 1.6 or 1.8xSUVmean of background (15.7 vs. 12.7 cm3; VOIs accurate in 49/50 and 46/50 patients, respectively). BTV based on striatum SUVmean was significantly smaller compared to the 1.6xSUVmean threshold only in surgically-treated patients (p=0.04), while no significant differences were highlighted compared to the 1.8xSUVmean threshold regardless of the patients' group. Conclusions: The ESTRO-EANO FET-PET thresholds proved to be interchangeable in patients scanned with [18F]DOPA-PET, while the use of a threshold based on the contralateral-striatum SUVmean provided partially overlapping results prompting further investigation.