Identifying Time Patterns of Highland and Lowland Air Temperature Trends in Italy and UK across monthly and annual scales

This paper presents a statistical analysis of air temperature data from 32 stations in Italy and the UK up to 2000 m above sea level, from 2002 to 2021. The data came from both highland and lowland areas, in order to evaluate both the differences due to location, and elevation. The analysis focused on detecting trends at annual and monthly time scales, employing both ordinary least squares (OLS), robust S-estimator regression, and Mann-Kendall (MK) and Sen’s slope methods. Then hierarchical clustering using Dynamic Time Warping (DTW) was applied to the monthly data to analyze the intra-annual pattern similarity of trends within and across the groups. Two different regions of Europe were chosen because of the different climate and temperature trends, namely the Northern UK (smaller trends) and the North-West Italian Alps (larger trends). The main novelty of the work is to show that stations having similar locations and altitudes have similar monthly slopes by quantifying them using DTW and clustering. These results reveal the nonrandomness of different trends along the year and among different parts of Europe, with a modest influence of altitude in wintertime. The findings revealed that group average trends were close to the NOAA values for the areas in Italy and the UK, confirming the validity of analyzing a small number of stations. More interestingly, intra-annual patterns were detected commonly at the stations of each of the groups, and clearly different between them. Confirming the different climates, most highland and lowland stations in Italy exhibit statistically significant positive trends, while in the UK, both highland and lowland stations show statistically nonsignificant negative trends. Hierarchical clustering in combination with DTW showed consistent similarity between monthly patterns of means and trends within the group of stations and inconsistent similarity between patterns across groups. The use of the twelve distance correlation matrices (dCor) (one for each month) also contributes to what is the main result of the paper, which is to clearly show the different temporal patterns in relation to location and (in some months) altitude. The anomalous behaviors detected at 3 of the 32 stations, namely Valpelline, Fossano and Aonoch Mor, can be attributed respectively to the fact that Valpelline is the lowest elevation station in its group, Fossano is the southernmost of the Italian stations, with some sublittoral influence, and Aonoch Mor has a large amount of missing values. In conclusion, these results improve our understanding of temperature spatio-temporal dynamics in two very different regions of Europe and emphasize the importance of consistent analysis of data to assess the ongoing effects of climate change. The intra-annual time patterns of temperature trends could be also compared with climate model results.