Clinical research is a fundamental component of scientific progress and drug development, traditionally divided into profit-driven studies promoted by industry and non-profit studies conducted by public bodies or independent institutions with the aim of improving clinical prac-tice. In Italy, non-profit research was long governed by a restrictive regulatory framework (Ministerial Decree of 17 December 2004), which significantly limited the possibility of exploiting research results for regulatory or commercial purposes, thereby hindering the development and impact of the evidence generated. The new Ministerial Decree of 30 November 2021 introduces a major shift by allowing the transfer of data and results from non-profit studies for regulatory purposes, fostering greater integration between the public sector and industry. However, the practical implementation of this reform presents several challenges, in-cluding the lack of clear criteria for the economic valuation of data, uncertainties regarding reimbursable costs, com-plexities related to data protection and informed consent, and a significant administrative burden on non-profit spon-sors. Additional issues concern data quality, the operational sustainability of the system, and restrictions on co-sponsor-ship, which may reduce the international competitiveness of Italian research. In conclusion, while the new regulatory framework represents a step forward in enhancing the value of independent research, further regulatory clarification and structural interventions are needed to ensure its effective implementation and to fully realize its potential.

Ricerca clinica senza scopo di lucro in Italia: opportunità e sfide irrisolte

Cagnazzo, Celeste
;
Fagioli, Franca
2026-01-01

Abstract

Clinical research is a fundamental component of scientific progress and drug development, traditionally divided into profit-driven studies promoted by industry and non-profit studies conducted by public bodies or independent institutions with the aim of improving clinical prac-tice. In Italy, non-profit research was long governed by a restrictive regulatory framework (Ministerial Decree of 17 December 2004), which significantly limited the possibility of exploiting research results for regulatory or commercial purposes, thereby hindering the development and impact of the evidence generated. The new Ministerial Decree of 30 November 2021 introduces a major shift by allowing the transfer of data and results from non-profit studies for regulatory purposes, fostering greater integration between the public sector and industry. However, the practical implementation of this reform presents several challenges, in-cluding the lack of clear criteria for the economic valuation of data, uncertainties regarding reimbursable costs, com-plexities related to data protection and informed consent, and a significant administrative burden on non-profit spon-sors. Additional issues concern data quality, the operational sustainability of the system, and restrictions on co-sponsor-ship, which may reduce the international competitiveness of Italian research. In conclusion, while the new regulatory framework represents a step forward in enhancing the value of independent research, further regulatory clarification and structural interventions are needed to ensure its effective implementation and to fully realize its potential.
2026
117
6
266
272
Clinical research; data transfer; independent research; infrastructures; non-profit
Cagnazzo, Celeste; Fagioli, Franca
File in questo prodotto:
Non ci sono file associati a questo prodotto.

I documenti in IRIS sono protetti da copyright e tutti i diritti sono riservati, salvo diversa indicazione.

Utilizza questo identificativo per citare o creare un link a questo documento: https://hdl.handle.net/2318/2156830
Citazioni
  • ???jsp.display-item.citation.pmc??? ND
  • Scopus 0
  • ???jsp.display-item.citation.isi??? ND
social impact